HomeMy WebLinkAboutCity Council Committees - Civil Services Commission - 09/10/1992 VSRB AGENDA: 9/10/92 @ 1200 VSRB 92-2
• --------------------------- KPCR 92-06459 (7/31/92 @ 1800
A. 1200: Board Discussion Facts, Law, Policy
1300: McVicar statement if offered.
1330: King Statement if offered.
1400: Formulation of Findings
1430: Deliberation and Voting
B. (Findings Needed for VSRB Report
C� 1. VSRB Packet sufficiency, reports adequate to reach a finding.
2 . policies and law:
a. 46 . 61. 035 -- Emergency vehicles U��-
b. 46. 61. 050 -- Obedience Traffic Control Devices
c. 46. 61 . 190 -- Yield Right of Way
d. K-09: Privileges afforded emergency vehicles
3 . Event Profile, OpeKA etc. /f
4 . Classification a ccident a Intentional acement Strikin .�4;&Wp` n(I
5 . Classification ionale f r as, non-preventable ((ll�J
Tc. C� � t/gLm��✓ra( !/ ti� �)�preventable E
�„ ea�, �imL cuyi 9r MOUC ) justifiable
�y IXA- 4tf� Aso d) non-justifiable 40
6. if p eventable/non-justifiable classification, unanimous
recommendation for sanctions, singularly or in combination,
a. no sanction
. b. mandated training, education, event assignment.
c. oral interview/warning
d. written reprimand
e. suspension
(Report is advisory to the Chief of Police)
Issues:
-- overhead lights on or not, not a significant issue
-- witnesses absence of overheads, leaning down,
-- probable acceleration just prior to or at moment .of switching
-- McVicar informed that he entered on a red-light.
-- Sun at 45 degree/horizon at 1800, summer night. 1
-- what would have been enforcement action if a, citizen? 'U 0/J
Remarks/Notes: ,PWUwV 'JdSoro+,a- 54N&d9q-07:Pw4-C 1.✓r&v�'>AC erO�
UGEfT� W�28 Oi✓ hT- ,119P/1e"r
n7o/edl - l d --7c) Cv�o09WVOIU OF 4ss�N>t-
Other
�S�r/uc7 ✓c�tu� /99l7U�/ 467- S7-0/'
Z w
3 = ai ii vj 2 U
a o >
F „ u
C N �. p•d � Z N C' v C Or ^J 6 T C �!•O O . ^ U ` � � 9 T� Y..tVT A C U V V Wf C' W
•J L.� ON Vl Nz Uv' YL y � V % � VL'A A _ TC C ° LNy = v 'O dVVCV Vl A � U
L '�O
❑ sv � s Nto
`
m0 > ° 3 > o � '-^ y v o A o � _ .. p A '^ o u u -• �Y " o % � N
p O U v N T� O v C y L y CO'j O C C N p U = V N C p
A T U O •Pi
'J U N ❑ C U A u y U N W U y A U G J L m �n
? yL � Uv a U AnONSLO O > n v .� TU C � Aum'� L4i9 � Cm , yL ti r4 V1 G
o C
dl pp O O ° � �O F .� y •v�• � C U C > C V
�vO O
c ` L •
O O C'mNOau.!.�;.i¢ UN= �E
U9XI
V �I ry^aAuV ,hrpnl NW WONG bKi .-LT•�
�C �3ArE u 'Y•m a F `� I > r` u
za Co
T
JIN C V L.. L Cp N C cl�� O> UAC_C pN• C vcV v oC a�y;V
ou�G O tVu
+IwEa
> cc
> oc ` Y:
L0uu
N
4, 9 T A > 3I V C S v .. G N �n W U T•p L O Y L O N_. _ _C .O C ri '3 L
W�� A O L U d1L .T ❑ v J •J C C `U T E �. C ' TJ O p�0 V O y t
�•I A u `v ,n e Z :f Y c n '^ Nial
A
NI C
/11 •f C N d > C:� U •p n C T p v� J u = � u _ t u C.'. C .E � > �C U C ?� O -a
=.JL!' `V c .0 .Il C W A L'•Ct L L c '� y `�^"' L � .-a _ .7� 7 d � 3::- j W .p L' L' .A^. o T Cu � E T ^.�
'' "' E v ai v 3 A c ^ .c
n ` Ti .. FG E n
^r Y A > > A > ... rn u ]II nC E A 7 A =0� A ` L O .0
_ vl cvtqu,_ 4 i� v ,°, op ^ � o p 'c � � A � c 3cc2 � .. = ... s .5 ch ar u 'o
7J :°n c K ,� a Y•i 'u n:o L ? c `
C J L .3 N G N T %u T '�. C u O E 'O L •O V � G= L � L � `p u y n y N Cll E K N y t > � L �
y T j w v .,-N,
y _ o = G u ro •.n o �n.3c v F ,. o` A t .y _ E A o K e❑ v € u ._ n v o` ..
> itl — � c L .�. U �= c w �p c.°_n u � U µµqq .-.s v 3 o F m�=a.T'w W �,-, a .•. v s c S' d L c �
C W E nv u 3 •� 5 � oT auLL ,_, C>I ^.,35 =^.p w.ve.�.. E.A..LBa _y�v� E � u > °r�'Q o.A w mm
WIw
o a c y c .�
er v >. o c T Y-• c: m u ._.. 3 ..
u c.= a E a > a u w
W1 U_I _T C O G r L t T N O> W y r V
C\ U O C O ._ _ Y 1 C ❑ n C ^Jl C d cc
.. J7 V l
c E = a c CI u.G ,3j > n s v i c > m `a av A `� > v r i N
ri F •' G � to � c � ZI CN LaE oAX .� u A_ uoco r r
I r0 A C�: A I O 3 L '�.0 UD U L y �•^ y U > T Y
v
V �p L U JI T o N m T` U 1�u1 L L = L E C U_ •V O C
> T u a a T O I^Ulll > T y n Y .0 C .= L L G A N N
.iO E o c ao ri
Wo2 .o 0 3c � a O .� � o o �C AEv3Aeom � 'ELco'v.om rnp.
U 3 `u v c U T o c
TO
•_ � ��°' z O n 3 n 'n C v �G zi.�� ti p s O L t L A V m N rn V O
v'� � •`Or .= u T d "oo �-° T v iii N .n > v T :I C:I .n � c S v o � E F E -° � aai�.; �u..-, rii a 3
F i U �y Y >` v c E F J C >� T >•.= C A :� c y _ c c oo wr `' >
O U�u.,qq e _ ,° ._ e+ OC uw u V .I WI e •2 _ c .=A•., � .E AL . o E
f (-^ � �.-
c
pTu - o TLN os vo '� � u �2•nv wr T v zw A' ' UA � wv
c Sri C T � `?
'.I o v 'C ?: v N d•°n v E `O H n c > a `
r+3
::H y U V L N U 9 A U C V y L•i L `p Y O G C V A t d
> y �u C > y a m c >� � �_c � m o a •c n E c�• 3
vi e E c cam^. ml 7 c w a`• y a c _ ,.T, c E s
g w C b I a T M OV v A C L 272
•I 1 C.2 A w_ L u .n L "J U •� N 7 ? p `a 0 r'l rT? _
T .r. � m.A.C
o C � T _ n vr•• o A Y c _ 9 „or g c^e
v C o _v _ V E E B G
>• 'y v '° > ^ u _ = L m_ u. y v E a c wo
O G Y u C n F V -J' ❑ u N A O y rC A q
p0 p O O d, L N L O '> > r A U `^ •T a� V W ' lt• p•� T O O VU V O L U
p .`i c y `v ^ s .. °'y a•L '� ° �. � a 5 n .. O � e w 'o s := a c � u c '� '
>• V 'J 'n L 011 u L fJ 'J r T n V C p C r'1 0. eIl (� C1 O °.y
ccO.
ZI y L a6s 9 C `• L w A •-•.
A O O C L- ` U O
2 U O rJ ,O U .0 B n H V fl
. •p ..Q N L�° T W T-W O V O V U O O C' E .S v O
C V V
yr d__ n _O 'n cc E 'J ^JI7 L C
�
a . T '�. •2 • o u N t a `C U O 5 e > U U .-. 3 0 •4 A •n m
c u o e o y v O C A v� c v N c y v<
— K Z o: • N K C A
Y L L j w 'L�WI '' T O rn N
w C C ` L O L .m !?
h y
L o ,% O W s
> a, F CI .,
A T y Y hf Z N L ` � 0:f, A 2i r• d p '1
u o ;n vOi 2 7 °>' .N u 'd' v v `v a° n =-� " u y a ' u i o>i o. E ,c, I� U v A
O y pO > L U U' '7 N A ` 0 0
U °
C vi I, CN > = A 2U A .�! G N v `� LT•U O •2' G� _^'. �O (-• b �°.,
J G OL O ` O. lL 'Z1' O A n O .CJLL^` O O >U ai v 'U'a ^J C m •O L' 'O P: Vl O'
U v tI,v >> O .� 't O
`o oc o v» CG
O o
_ y°• `y .7 C •J T F �' U = U AO C L A :'J- A 'J N ° C - C .A..-L O..Q C ,� W T
cS
> L • a vpon U dnr CO 3AN
rn UCI F ` e= = yu ' 'moo oZ oL 'E i� F-' J
2•uL �� C� �. .^... NOGJ 6'C Urr .G.' C. 0 > J ''J nrf riled dO `n A '� nvn C p5Nv U`/. a. v v>
'J1I j
Ou Td S y �L.j L ` .0 in = Ly ° c'. •° L N
rqa .en
• :n C O C
> A °
j L
Z y J
> G
'' � •ll .� O.^ W U C N N ... OU r O
T'J L O V L 'J .N. C O S
y `�
c ^ E c E E ° _"c_ 0
^I Uc O o L O V N O E
d N
Ti � C L L 6 W lL � 'C_ O 'Q C T O N Cti'• L y s 11 U C t J Q C �1:`� G C vNdiN C > b J N C •U O N
4 -
y � n
U L> .� u
Y utI
G >
E u H
OG � •o -r a.. C .^_.35 _°.4 c:�� fia5
O Wa �c U `oq �.^. 2 @@o.. E r +ice P. 5 �' F - - sop .gua
. .7. tn PG. .. . 5 3a..'�.v� �. �i o mG � o .. .ti^
PUT.'+ cy's bE 'v'CL �•a a— o '.�• .-q
a • V>uo u>y Ou $c Vuc0�UE.A_u0 .Eq.GYO EoaO Ac •QcN uU u°S'aotn E c5 " ;a
° b.S ou2o E3
3u E c3 0oc U owu 0 � E c ° °'6 E uu ex ` - 0 wdo6"bwA
owu3,
E
oE .L c v snu u roc .c
2 « WTyT—E UN ro` uL u
E m2 .E
U'ucA rl i�9ycm�0°'9°c� aWO�.Y�"���+eG�BOE.uqA3Ef`c=O`a� ?.�yEaC oUE.aQdE•�a ze1°..OKy°j syLo{ NUoc'.vu D'�v0c°m>0oa`i oUGnE sm`�Eu ccEO' u'0YroE' 0u�Y6OY uc u 'NEm'tUy s9A cu Eac oT Luo c� °m? aOc" LLLo n.CGE oua O'.e�0c
E E ywmm o.E c 0E0EV'..7VcGu uo' 'os
E c od0 yo ` c0__ >u16 m u o
cu o .Do . .y
° 0 > 0L ` O U y e
>tOc
oc2 o u rz
E0E3 ° ' L , -t � 'c `0Em 000 yq ,GoA
a m E > odc
u.9n ' ° odn m : o E� yoro E 0 s Wur m
- U V 'OL ' ; Naoa¢Uc> y U
uy O w 8n ce 'cu U> eA E
E,yAApmEEmGy
..H,sm=uCGamouE
v
c
O U c L U c' y L �J' ..Y. C U T ° .L 2 O O tpG,1 O ` E y L O V L O >` 0 0 0 L E L w
Fy C LdppyvmC Ca OV YO L. ymA.0 AU � � � O'J C4 'o AdOLN
-2 m pE y. OW O T > V U A_ 'a �TNs
U a U Y A D,cY .0 O b N _. `
� o- uuH > � °' � epcp� "u TvE °c � 'c a .n u � EY ZzWuw
ro _ y
T9 12
O E s m�a oEA E = oOO Ty 6Er uEULa° 'A aA3v yA yu w390
-ac > o0- C ma u ' Wa Yy� -Wv-i Nu`
t NE L
WU 0 mA Cp N a 0 Ou WQc-
NO
V OCO V m C U
as 14G � S c .. s o = Exo " u ° u c E �= A= cs ° aE cW =° u 'UEo
yL 6L. 0 V .-", ,tlpy � m = m.Y. 00 ." O ACW ._
\e3UCYW1 �S�-c°°'•.L� =°c0 yy mc a.d.a`�o :'. v Sd AydAUu 0 O O °ue
uO 'L?�3
Oco C N uLcw
uo "
> 6 00O 4 p �u '�m 3 •UE� LoyUC '•LE mOEoU iLY ° UYi aU
mCa9 c � m ' it 044.. Cm
0 o s w 0 m tu > 'oogu°O t: naCnm o�NuO° coOU
vC-sm
o c E .0 o
E � > os .u- o ° � clm !0u! . —Sa2a2EEOd .. O" 2p� "sC_ RPSwc!cuWL�
>`O ° .Nw ^Vl p c C m'G L _' S �A. q .. rO 0 0 ° cF m O0 0 0�. W.
t ,�O a '� fO rs�. b 00 OD ° ` q p L m N Y O:G A O'O^ L E > Y Y N 9 °.N C i•'C 00 Y � O� C
p 00 0� � 'V� C u r°`n V O U u N .G, a y O y ` •O O NC u C T c rG .Y.. oQp_
ms N ° r 9 Y V7 -p O w L'C.r N m= m YN O 9 L N N Y ° y Y�Y. O u N C Y a N OO O
c � uw aae o �a w � yaoa gapa � Yas � o :°w � uw my .Gs ohM w
C� 6 L= eT ^ w• a'3 C A N a O N LGn C A O C Y u .Y-
J ra O a oGe 6 C y T a m L.0 Gns m 'E r�o .N.. h L U.•y Y C r A C m ••'G �O b C
L l�1 9 iv U rr 6 p N U O V� O a°i d a 0 WQf VJ
H O .N.r T° >, a a 'G"'; c m` " Y•O N s A u VV
> nYmT u� u Qr^.y� wr0`nY+,'•L'c boTOcY`.dn'r�rfoTAOm> t'r uC y6Nm qhV MO QoQGU1�0:yeTE` NC^ av_Y a.Qi cYi W'tu vmCG°O L^q Q3 cC9As O3V`cm°: �='Nia°" O:iuo'�°'rD6Y'cE"° L'NLmY �cPLNG �;Ou, �noyu�C=ts'Yn�'UuuN[9uw.mGO.�u'E �ouy s'.gOA�' mC Au scYYmC vCA`mc°9yL u=am v=um°m-oA�Cc.- aY:po°n:' �r�;�rpVq...�,ti�LbOraq'',cW^Nmpmti,o
3 e _"M W N
9 0c t ��uo C C 0 u >
omo$� sc�E
pa 'c ad P C . C
p oP LE u iUU uO €
0H G0u O y`9 O O C gh N 'C '` u E
h a_rroY
Q O uO C h : . y E Xyo. 0 ZhQUai:a . q
A 0-
FW uma.9T'ayypYONmOCCn,m•GCom:popum%YCAC'.=vOoNoumm•oa�Yu`mCUpcY'''xW.`urNN``YcY.e,=wL'AcV.ocYu�'_uo°aamY°Y>e, 'cWvom�`LoGO w`u.Yd orN`u ut=UO 'UpO teNrm s:NGA0:n•v•'aCLAY_�- L•N.YvYGaY,i
_ 4U'=YT_aOa:C°-•.F'r_�OrumLN
v_N'ur.�Oumu'r^'CnGi
VYcAoN"cOCLNY°m A O
Y cm G
7�2 °
o N a n c0
> O o peG ° U- C 'o t 60 O LZ O °O O V9t ^A ` oy9O
u YTy O
.9 4u U w nC t 0`e ° Os oE m = %a'd
GA Cu m ti � 9
0 ` 0
nAY AOyp9O
° L z U .F
°wt " L Y aw ULYND
u !n G U G N m
O A OTu >C
tA
o 0 ae
Y 0 NY . h , UT oy ° 5 ^ 9QO Km .°
it
E ri T T o ° Y cpnV �m � a
o 9ca � Cy
c 0
u o Y
y ` � `� ° m o $ c u Ec .o QF $ 'ud > 3mu >
cwO _c Y 0 O
oomEE E a o Zw mn5s C
6 :c o..m�. u `o.
y d N= v u u 0 i° c7 ous
C^ y .0 V >. w u Y ° m V m m O N
cmuc ° N .ecm� � c39 �n Q ^s♦ u3
E t O E T N C Z Y r0 Y` L
A'% Ca m T CO pm TVY V.0 TO L > Ct > O TL .Y.. CO
y q A C'-
C `°L•C0 d a .u. u C N O rYj Q O N 0 '�. a`� m N _ro y 0
u A ._ > Ousb upo.a_ rA > °a 0o .a
eA>s uu vA�� a ou 0v cm aT cep *cEE au`
vo � da Y i = ' t � v sE
Ire,
o
.a.r. WV °eU.°' rn s3N 9itcp-YS suEi rwuT m' u w••rnN =� �rPno Gi rwn t"vI i�) .cn�rug�y�u unAo scrn u�u rn�i -`•°a- :wmuu'wm e Nst°j qm r"u75 -ySuo wu c wustAc-s 'E•u�u
Ygyw N 9 Yc ° nN=3cOc
'a E C uY u U N O Z TC
9 mc, U= O os uc
l.
cm_ yY r
C GEu c ow , >` '>eE so p 0. c 2 u ua w cec
O � u u $m > % ccc $ ws-
:
Q.
...w v ..- om M�0Z) > 4a .0
a .Cl
c it
O C
b
Q
W C m o Q u �a o e w '" S p ` y
c d w o 0 o v7 Y N
F asGo e�e�,,� ua `Yu v�i a u o u E c `m aS7 c4 'O � 0 0
'3 = Yuvu .�cN = u �i m
> ` u u
N T d c u
c "' $ o`u_ o.V .S m yU o cw
��rwL 1O u au ,o uw c Y I Ev 'r c Y °= m _N
d O C p rO •.r.O a U o w O O u 6 p O O•O Jn C w'y y E W ° T Y C C W
• aeoos '�'o e 'G :: OwU =°• � ouo > a m_`.° u a 2ry wP'.
A OVI C F O L O E U U C °' Y p, Y yy E A u W O
A p m w u u F �' a o a ° a o e 3 o ri o h n o Y
eG m $ro c rsu° sY. rn > v) m a an,m E.a = run c Y u Y Y P
5 Y c u Y u T $qy^! n " p O._m > 9 .E 9 e
JC O u "' N C u c. b U ° O N C N"� u O.aC - C M.O , Y O T� C U Y N V
o `m E E 9 n r w u -ac m m °'y•p s .mom. rc`n c d ° +%+ E u E c.' .�+ °i' m m
T Gn _ ti OS A E A p C 6`ON m •" Y Y .. � p u U A U
� p � pYp-: NLOAto
I � Q,' � YTOOYC _Ei `Z..W Gn yC � _y O.U � vl � OI
O A L O C A E °� >. Y A m°r C > u y ° c E O :p t Y Gn.Y m C u q 6 O p �•
LS p C . vl O 'a N .O y 'U C Y O C `O C r y Y Y W ...
m mY CLO > O .Sm U �i7OWW VNwt .yT FV 'G � rn rri •V Nr'] O